The problem did not start there however. It seems that there has been confusion about the colour of Sam the Eagle's feet since the heyday of the Muppet Show in the late 1970s. This is understandable as the original puppet of Sam the Eagle did not have any feet. Below is a photo I took of a photo from page 74 of the "Of Muppets and Men" book, published in 1981. It shows Frank Oz performing Sam the Eagle, and there are no feet on the puppet. Why? Because there is no need for legs on a puppet if the puppet is only going to be seen from the waist up on camera.
The same book shows the original sketch Jim Henson made for Sam the Eagle (page 77). The sketch is of Sam's head only, without a body, and especially without feet. I had always thought the Muppet Treasure Island was the first time Sam's feet were seen on camera, but it turns out I was wrong. The Muppet Wiki site shows a picture of Sam and his feet from the Muppet Movie (1979). Unfortunately the photo is in black and white, but the feet do not look light enough in colour to be yellow. I'll have to watch the movie again and pay closer attention.
However Sam was then depicted in several Muppet Show children's books with blue feet. Okay not several...just two of them. The first one is "Robin Hood" published in 1980. The Muppet Wiki site shows a photo of him from the book (which I don't have in my collection).
Notice his blue feet! This image is found at this Muppet Wiki link:
The second book is called "Two for the Show" (published in 1982) and features two pictures of Sam with blue feet, shown below.
Now for those of you who are still not convinced that Sam's feet should be blue, here are some illustrations from the comic book pages of Muppet Magazine!
Muppet Magazine, Winter 1984, page 46...Sam as a child with blue feet! (Back when he wasn't such a bald eagle... wocka-wocka!)
Muppet Magazine, Spring 1984, page 44...another picture of Sam with blue feet... underneath his shoes!
Muppet Magazine, Spring 1985, page 31... after six years with blue feet they suddenly turn yellow? I'd say something's a-foot!!! Wocka-wocka! I'm such a heel!
Muppet Magazine, Winter 1986, page 27.... the brown shoes return, and are far better than yellow feet!
Muppet Magazine, Winter 1988, page 21.... Sam has blue feet again! See how natural they look.
Then of course there is "The Muppet Show Book", published in 1978 before all of the above examples. This book shows Sam the Eagle on the front cover with orange chicken legs!
Here is a closer look at the scrawniness of Sam's chicken legs. This predates even the Muppet Movie photo showing Sam's feet and is likely the first time Sam was ever seen with feet. Mind you, in no way should this veto all of his apperances with blue feet over the years, as clearly he had blue feet more often than yellow! However....
Fast forward to Muppet Treasure Island, released in 1996, and wham-o! Sam's feet are yellow again! Not just yellow, but scrawny, tiny and yellow with little spikey claws. What were the puppet builders thinking? Could it be they used the above "Muppet Show Book" cover as reference for making Sam's feet for this shot? Didn't they do any other research to see that in fact Sam's feet should have been blue? How could they not know about the 1979 PVC figure with blue feet? The complete set of those PVC Muppet figures have been hanging from the chandelier in the foyer of the Henson Company's New York townhouse on East 69th Street since 1979!
Above is the picture from the Muppet Wiki site showing Sam the Eagle's yellow feet. It is found at this link:
http://muppet.wikia.com/wiki/Sam_the_Eagle These feet look nothing like the feet Sam has in the B&W Muppet Movie photo shown at the top of this page, which I prefer. And why shouldn't Sam have blue feet? Many of his fellow Muppets have had blue feet for years with great success, such as Gonzo, Zoot, Thog, Uncle Deadly, a Big Blue Frog, Cookie Monster, Grover, Fat Blue, Boober Fraggle, Tutter and others.
I think the most important question to answer is this: Why didn't the puppet builders know that blue beak = blue feet? Camilla has an orange beak and her feet are orange. And there's also Big Bird. His beak is yellow and his legs...um...let's not bring Big Bird into this, he's from a separate franchise!
None the less, I have further evidence that Sam's feet are supposed to be blue! For here, I present another children's book based on the very same movie from whence the yellow feet appeared. "Muppet Treasure Island: Treasure Hunt" (1996) shows the following picture of Sam, not with yellow feet, but with blue feet!!!!
Unfortunately, it seems the blue feet only momentarily prevailed as from this point on the yellow feet caught on with toy manufacturers. And wouldn't you know it, now that the Muppets are back in vogue and collectable as ever, new action figures and toys are popping up everywhere. Sam has been made in plush form for the first time, and as an action figure for the first time, and several other times! Take a look below at some of the cool Sam the Eagle offerings of recent years, all of which have yellow feet!!!
This one is a PVC figure.
These two, above and below, are articulated action figures with yellow feet.
This is a Kubrick figure. I found the image at this website:
This is the Star Wars Muppets action figure of Sam the Eagle as Obi-Wan Kenobi available only at Disney theme parks in 2011. I found this photo at the this link:
This is quite possibly the first ever Sam the Eagle plush toy. The photo is from an e-bay auction:
And so, fellow Muppet collectors, I submit that all of these collectables have been ruined. Ruined I say! All because of the yellow feet. Alas, how many more Sam the Eagle action figures and stuffed toys must be ruined in this way? Have the Muppet puppet builders no shame? End the confusion! Correct this travesty before it gets any further out of hand. Replace Sam the Eagle's yellow feet with the blue feet he was always meant to have! Someone get Frank Oz on the phone!!!